Hamburger Menu IconMenu Close Icon
Special Needs

Self-Direction vs. Traditional OPWDD Services

What’s the difference, and which is better for your family?

layer 41

Once your child is granted OPWDD eligibility, you can apply for waiver services – which can provide life-changing support. OPWDD services can be accessed traditionally, or via self-direction. 

Choosing the best service structure for your family can feel overwhelming. You may be wondering what self-direction is, how it differs from traditional services, and if it’s the right way for you to get services. 

Hamaspik’s intake team supports hundreds of families each year as they navigate this important decision, offering clear guidance on both available paths. This guide outlines the key differences between the two options so you can move forward with confidence and clarity.

Self-Direction vs. Traditional Services: The Core Difference

Self-direction offers you more freedom to shape your services by giving you a budget to allocate to approved services, rather than a set number of service hours. With self-direction, you have more control and flexibility over how you access support and how much you pay your providers.

Self-direction also comes with more responsibility, paperwork, and hands-on management. It tends to work best for individuals and families who want to be actively involved in planning and managing services.

In contrast, traditional services deliver support via a defined number of approved hours for each service. Hamaspik handles all paperwork and coordinates support workers and programs, providing structured support with minimal hands-on management. This option works well for families seeking predictable, reliable services without administrative responsibility.

By understanding both approaches, you can decide which option best fits your family’s needs, preferences, and capacity right now.

How services are structured

Your self-direction budget can be allocated to several approved areas such as respite care, community classes, transportation, and other approved supports. While you can hire providers of your choice at your preferred rate, all services and expenses must meet specific program guidelines.

In the traditional setup, you receive a set number of hours for each eligible service, and providers are paid the set OPWDD rate.

Beyond what services you receive, it’s also important to understand who will be working with you under each structure.

Who’s on your team?

Whichever service structure you choose, your Hamaspik coordinator will guide you and serve as your point of contact to help you access services.

With self-direction, you’ll start by working with a broker — chosen by you, or provided by Hamaspik when available. Your broker helps create your budget and submit initial documentation.

Once you begin services, you’ll be assigned a dedicated coordinator who acts as the Fiscal Intermediary (FI), handling the government funds and paying providers based on the paperwork you submit. Our Preapprovals team manages any additional preapprovals required for certain expenses (such as classes, memberships, or household-related items).

With traditionally structured services, you’ll work with a dedicated coordinator who creates a plan that ensures you’ll get the most out of your services — from connecting you with excellent-fit respite workers and providers to recommending helpful programs and guiding you every step of the way.

What you’ll be responsible for

With self-directed services, every expense in your budget must be documented with receipts and required paperwork. You’ll have to obtain and maintain all required documentation. 

Your broker and FI coordinator will meet with you monthly to collect documents, review spending, and make sure your budget is up to date. As with all OPWDD services, your support workers will clock in and out using a specific app, and you’ll need to approve your providers’ timesheets.

With traditional services, there’s little-to-no paperwork or ongoing updates for families, other than approving providers’ timesheets. 

Costs and budget structure

There is no out of pocket cost for any OPWDD services. 

With self-direction, the broker’s rate is called a “fringe rate” and it’s built into the overall overall budget. Hamaspik’s fringe rate is only 18% of the total budget – lower than the NYS average 26%.

Budget FAQs

Does the fringe rate reduce my services?

Every self-direction budget will include a percentage paid out to the broker (the “fringe rate”) built into the overall budget structure. It doesn’t come as an extra bill, but it does affect how the total budget is allocated across services. The lower your fringe rate, the less of your budget goes to your broker’s fees and the more you have for services.

Why is Hamaspik’s fringe rate only 18%?

Hamaspik’s internal systems and efficiencies enable us to keep our broker rate low – so only 18% of your total budget is allocated to broker fees.

Can I run out of a budget mid-year?

Yes, if spending isn’t monitored carefully, this can happen. That’s why monthly budget tracking meetings are required. Overspending early in the year can mean insufficient funds later. Planning is important.

layer 36
asset 31
layer 37
asset 32
layer 38
asset 33
layer 36
asset 31
layer 37
asset 32
layer 38
asset 33
layer 36
asset 31
layer 37
asset 32
layer 38
asset 33
layer 37
asset 32
layer 38
asset 33
layer 38
asset 32

Auditory Sensitivity

My child is sensitive to loud noises
(e.g., sirens, vacuum cleaner).

My child seeks out specific sounds or types of music and appears calmer when listening to them.

Tactile Sensitivity

My child is irritated by certain fabrics or tags in clothing.

My child seems indifferent to sensations that are usually painful or to extreme temperatures.

Visual Sensitivity

My child is sensitive to bright or flashing lights.

My child tends to avoid eye contact.

Taste/Smell Sensitivity

My child constantly prefers bland foods and rejects foods with strong flavors or spices.

My child seeks out strong or unusual smells, such as sniffing food or objects.

Proprioceptive Sensitivity

My child prefers tight hugs or being wrapped in a blanket.

My child is unaware of body position in space (e.g., often bumps into things).

Social Sensitivity

My child becomes anxious or distressed in crowded spaces.

Movement Sensitivity

My child dislikes fast or spinning movements

Vestibular Sensitivity

My child is hesitant or resistant to climbing or balancing activities (e.g., jungle gyms, see-saws).

Please answer all questions before submitting.

Your Child’s Score is

  • 0-15

    Low Sensory Sensitivity

  • 16-30

    Moderate Sensory Sensitivity

  • 31-45

    High Sensory Sensitivity

  • 46-60

    Very High Sensory Sensitivity

0-15: Low Sensory Sensitivity

  • Interpretation: Your child exhibits low levels of sensory sensitivity, usually falling within the typical developmental range.
  • Recommendation: Generally not  a cause for concern. If you have specific worries or notice a sudden change in behavior, consult a healthcare professional for a comprehensive evaluation.
  • 0-15

    Low Sensory Sensitivity

  • 16-30

    Moderate Sensory Sensitivity

  • 31-45

    High Sensory Sensitivity

  • 46-60

    Very High Sensory Sensitivity

16-30: Moderate Sensory Sensitivity

  • Interpretation: Your child displays moderate sensory sensitivity, which may warrant intervention.
  • Recommendation: Consider sensory-friendly activities, sensory sensitive toys, or sensory sensitive clothing like noise-canceling headphones and weighted blankets to improve comfort. If symptoms persist, consult health care professionals.
  • 0-15

    Low Sensory Sensitivity

  • 16-30

    Moderate Sensory Sensitivity

  • 31-45

    High Sensory Sensitivity

  • 46-60

    Very High Sensory Sensitivity

31-45: High Sensory Sensitivity

  • Interpretation: Your child has higher than average sensory sensitivity that may interfere with daily functioning.
  • Recommendation: Seek a detailed evaluation by health care professionals for sensory integration therapy options and potential environmental modifications.
  • 0-15

    Low Sensory Sensitivity

  • 16-30

    Moderate Sensory Sensitivity

  • 31-45

    High Sensory Sensitivity

  • 46-60

    Very High Sensory Sensitivity

46-60: Very High Sensory Sensitivity

  • Interpretation: Your child demonstrates high levels of sensory sensitivity that could significantly interfere with daily life.
  • Recommendation: If your child displays this level of sensory sensitivity, it’s highly recommended that you consult with a health care professional for a multi-disciplinary assessment. You will probably be directed towards early intervention programs and specialized support.

Intake timeline and getting started

The intake process is significantly different for the two service options. 

After receiving OPWDD eligibility, you can immediately apply for waiver services if you’re opting to receive services traditionally.

If opting for self-directed services, the intake process is extended. 

First, parents attend a required introductory webinar. Next, you’ll connect with a self-direction broker to create your budget. After that, you’ll join Hamaspik’s self-direction waitlist, with a standard wait time of 5–6 weeks. Finally, your broker submits the budget for approval and refines it as needed. The total time –— from receiving OPWDD eligibility until beginning services — typically takes 6–7 months. 

The wait time for self-direction can be frustrating, especially after the extended process of applying for OPWDD eligibility. For that reason, most families opt to start with traditional services immediately — without impacting their ability to apply for self-direction services at the same time. This way, they can get support while they wait.

3 questions to help you decide between self-direction and traditional services

The questions below can help you get clearer on which option may be a better fit for your family.

1. Do you have the capacity to be involved in managing services, paperwork, budgets, and meetings?

• Yes, that’s not a problem for me

→ Self-direction may be a good fit for you

• No, I’d prefer less hands-on involvement

→ Traditional services are likely a better fit

2. What type of support will best fit your child’s needs?

• More flexibility to access specific community classes or lessons

→ Self-direction may be a good fit for you

• More ongoing support

→ Traditional services are likely a better fit

3. What matters more to you right now?

• More flexibility in how my hours are used

→ Self-direction may be a good fit for you

• More steady support hours, managed by my coordinator

→ Traditional services are likely a better fit

Moving forward

The decision can feel confusing. And the truth is, there’s no universally better option — only the option that fits your family’s current reality.

If you’re feeling unsure and overwhelmed, it may be best to start with what gives you support fastest and reduces your stress, instead of increasing it. You can always begin with traditional services for immediate relief, and request self-direction at any time.

And remember — at any time, you can change your service structure to better fit your current needs.

Whether you choose traditional services, self-direction, or begin with one and transition later — we’re here to guide you step by step. If you’d like help thinking through your specific situation, reach out to speak with one of our service specialists. You don’t have to figure this out alone.

Hands Full Parenting: Creating Structure that Sticks

Cut the Confusion: Discover the Process for Accessing Services

Making Purim Work for Your Child

Self-Direction vs. Traditional OPWDD Services

Hands Full Parenting: Helping Your Preemie Thrive

Understanding Intervention Options

How OPWDD Evaluations Work: A Step-by-Step Guide

Social Scripts for Kids at Family Gatherings

Hands Full Parenting: Growing Through Adolescence

Never Say Never

Recognizing CVI: Ten Characteristics

Understanding CVI

Dancing with Crutches

Sight Unseen

Structure on Days Off

Inclusion Without Overwhelm

To Tell or Not to Tell

Rose Colored Glasses

Summer’s Secret Skills

Recognizing Early Signs of Autism

A Hug from Above

Smart, Simple Camp Prep for Kids With Special Needs

Hands Full Parenting: Sibling Rivalry & Negative Behavior

The Colors of the Spectrum

The Essential Guide to Outings with Kids with Special Needs

Hands Full Parenting: Navigating Tantrums

How Do I Get OPWDD Approval?

Indoor Winter Sensory Adventures

Defining IDD Levels and Severity

Life Skills for Individuals with Intellectual Disabilities

The Sensory-Smart Gift Guide

Spina Bifida: Early Intervention

Nothing to Hide

Hands Full Parenting: Aggression & Emotional Health

Yom Tov Transitions Made Easy

NYC’s Top Accessible Adventures

The Yom Tov Parenting Survival Guide

Understanding OPWDD Eligibility: What You Need to Know

How Direct Support Professionals Enhance Quality of Life

What Is Com Hab and How Does It Provide Individualized Support?

6 Benefits of Respite Care for Families of Kids with Special Needs

Encouragement for the First Day of School

What is Spina Bifida? An Overview

My Life in Holland

Fostering Independence in Children With IDD

Understanding IDD

What is Epilepsy?

Defining Signs of Dyslexia

Hands Full Parenting: Becoming the Therapist I Needed

Understanding Down Syndrome

Early Intervention for Down Syndrome

Our Roller Coaster Ride

Understanding Cerebral Palsy

Understanding Autism

Autism Support

Sensory Processing Sensitivity Test

Decoding Diagnostic Tests

The Ultimate Child Development Checklist

Cut the Confusion: Discover the Process for Accessing Services

Is My Child’s Religiosity OCD?

Empowering Emotional Intelligence

Managing Panic Attacks

Understanding Social Anxiety Disorder

Confronting Childhood Trauma

How to Support a Family Member with Anxiety

Understanding Separation Anxiety

Understanding Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)

Mental Health Disorder Prevention

Combating Depression in the Elderly

Understanding Depression

Understanding Anxiety

Adult ADHD Action Plan

Helping Kids Sleep Better: Sleep Strategies for Anxiety

Hands Full Parenting: Helping Your Preemie Thrive

Understanding Intervention Options

How OPWDD Evaluations Work: A Step-by-Step Guide

Recognizing CVI: Ten Characteristics

Understanding CVI

Sight Unseen

To Tell or Not to Tell

Rose Colored Glasses

Recognizing Early Signs of Autism

Spina Bifida: Early Intervention

A Parent's Guide to Cooking for Kids With Food Allergies

Early Intervention for Down Syndrome

Understanding Speech and Language Development

Helping Kids Sleep Better: Sleep Strategies for Anxiety

Sensory Processing Sensitivity Test

Strategies for Feeding a Picky Eater

Simple Sensory Activities to Try with Your Child

Decoding Diagnostic Tests

The Ultimate Child Development Checklist

Categories